I know that this is an old post, but I don't know why I never saw this before. Then for some reason it was pulled up when I responded to another totally unrelated post...
"Temperment: Aussies are intelligent, active, good natured dogs who are perfect for families.
Australian Shepherds are known for their laid back, playful, and friendly nature."
I'd like to know where this info was gotten because ... wow. I hope this isn't being put out as fact somewhere.
I happen to mostly agree with the original poster, sorry. Aussies should never be touted as "The Great Family Dog"! Aussies are not laid back and they are not supposed to be overly friendly and good natured towards strangers. Maybe this was meant a different way, but to me these words describe a Labradog/Golden type personality. Which is the total OPPOSITE of what an Aussie is supposed to be... actually that is the reason why I love them so much.
Aussies are supposed to be a reserved guardian breed, with a high herding instinct. Reserved meaning standoffish and not running up to great & love random people. They will accept petting from strangers, but they could care less if they give it to them. Unchannelled herding instinct leads to kids & people getting nipped, chasing cars, bikes and a strong desire to control movement. They desperately NEED work to do, if not they WILL come up with something and believe me, you probably WON'T like it.
They can be A great family dog, but they are not "Great Family Dogs", if you get my drift.
*off soapbox*
~moni